What to do with the new-age Peter Forsberg and Joe Sakic (or even Steve Yzerman and Sergei Fedorov, I suppose)? Just as in their day, many wondered how to best utilize supremely talented natural centers when two wind up on the same team. Should they be used together often at even strength? Or just when the team needed a goal or shot in the arm? Or hardly ever at all, regardless of the situation? I believe the Avs and Red Wings tried a mixture of all these schools of thoughts over parts of several different seasons.
Arguments for using a regular Malkin/Crosby even strength line:
+ Supremely skilled players play at a higher level when they’re with like minded players. Things were easier (not to mention happier) when a guy named Jaromir Jagr got to play with Ron Francis and Mario Lemieux and not carry a line of scrubs like Kip Miller and Josef Beranek.
+ Lack of consistent skill wingers. Colby Armstrong has been great the last handful of games, but he’s proven to be a pretty inconsistent point producer. Same can be said of Ryan Malone. Petr Sykora and Jordan Staal certainly have the skill, but both have had disappointing seasons in statistical categories for long stretches. Erik Christensen and Georges Laraque have had limited chances with Malkin, and for good reason, both have stunk in top 6 roles and shouldn’t even be in the argument.
+ It will open more up (in theory) for others. Surely opponents will have to use their #1 checking forward line and their #1 defenseman to do everything possible to limit Crosby and Malkin. This should, in theory, let guys like Malone, Staal and Sykora play against weaker defensive forwards and defenseman which should translate into more chances and goals for them.
+ Keeps them on the same page. Fimiliarity, obviously, is a good thing. Every practice, every shift, these two become a little more in sync with each other’s tendencies, strengths and weaknesses and that should benefit all aspects of their game. You have to play these guys together more often than just the powerplay and having them on the same line should create more cohesion. Let’s not forget these guys are 20 and 21 year olds and have been in the same lineup for probably about 115 games. They hardly have the rapport of a duo that’s been together for years, for obvious reasons, it has to come from experience playing together.
+ To maximize both players ice time. At even strength Therrien is pretty good about rolling four lines and there’s been criticism that he doesn’t play Crosby and Malkin enough. Obviously it’d be easier to play them more if they’re playing together.
Arguments for splitting up Crosby and Malkin at even strength:
- It makes the Penguins a 1 line team. As mentioned, you know the opponents shutdown units are going to be 100% focused on the top line. And if they do keep the big guns off the scoreboard it’s going to mean the team as a whole is struggling. Secondary scoring hasn’t been as good as expected anyways.
- Malkin is a natural center anyways. Malkin’s size, vision and playmaking ability means he’s a natural at center. He should not be used in a position where he might not be able to utilize 100% of his skills and ability.
- To make others better. Crosby has had gotten good stretches of play out of guys like Armstrong and Malone. The same can be said for Malkin with Staal (last season) and Sykora. The secondary players aren’t producing now, but perhaps their best bet is to still be played with these talented centers and not left to fend for themselves.
As you can see, there’s good arguments pro and con. Personally we here believe that the current course of action is right: leave them together now because the team needs the offensive boost without Fleury and the two are playing darn well right now. In the future, while I don’t think they should be permanent linemates, I think there’s good reason to keep experimenting with it for more situations than just at the end of the game if the team needs a goal.
And, as a bonus, here’s two potential line combinations (done by me) for both scenarios. Feel free to pipe up in the comments and say what you like better or suggest your own. Everyone loves to play coach when you can’t take the blame of a loss!
Malkin-Crosby-Armstrong
Malone-Staal-Sykora
Kennedy-Christensen-Laraque
Ruutu-Taffe-Hall
Malone-Crosby-Armstrong
Staal-Malkin-Sykora
TK-EC-BGL
Ruutu-Taffe-Hall
Since there’s only 12 forwards, all with pretty defined roles, there’s not much room for switching around.
Thursday, January 3, 2008
Roster Analysis and Thoughts on Toronto
Four weeks ago tonight the Penguins season was very, very uncertain. Barely above .500, the only goaltender thought to be of NHL starting caliber went down. How has the team responded? How about going on a 104 point pace (taking 14 out of 22 possible points) and vaulting to the top half of the Eastern Conference shuffle.
Last year the team didn’t have much adversity to deal with and almost coasted to a 105 point season. This year, important players (Marc-Andre Fleury, Max Talbot, Mark Eaton, Gary Roberts) are dropping like flies with long-term injuries and new players like Ty Conklin, Rob Scuderi and Tyler Kennedy are not only stepping into expanded roles, they’re flourishing.
Of the injuries, Talbot is starting to skate a little, but still on his own. His return is probably weeks away to get healthy and in game shape, but we here think his return is definitely on the horizon. After all, when Gary Roberts went down it left the Penguins with 12 healthy forwards, the minimum number. Michel Therrien doesn’t like to change a lineup during a winning streak, so it wouldn’t make much sense to callup a young forward like Ryan Stone or Jonathan Filewich to ride the bench instead of playing in the A. But they haven’t even called up a depth forward like Connor James, and obviously winning streaks don’t last forever. Plus, unfortunately, injuries do happen and another forward could go down or become ill. That the Penguins haven’t called up another forward, seems to indicate, to me, that Talbot may be getting back into the lineup sooner rather than later.
Defensively the Penguins only have 6 healthy blueliners on the roster. However I’m not that surprised about that. All are healthy and playing their respective roles relatively well. The most likely callup, Alain Nasreddine, would have to be exposed to re-entry waivers if they want to call him up. Nasreddine is a pretty decent 6/7 depth defenseman and it wouldn’t surprise me to see another NHL club claim him, especially since he’d only be owed about ¼ of a season’s salary (because the Penguins would be required to pay half of his remaining salary which, at this point in the season, is about half paid). Why expose Naz (a former captain and veteran leader of the Baby Pens) to waivers if you don’t need to? Why callup a guy like Ryan Lannon if he’s just going to sit the bench anyways? Neither scenario makes much sense; as there’s little to gain and much more to lose.
If/when the Penguins need to fill a roster spot that’s when you can try to sneak Nasreddine back up, or look to make a trade for a depth defenseman. Until then, with guys like Sydor and Orpik playing better and Letang playing well in general, it’s OK to me to stand pat.
Back to the game, as I mentioned the Penguins are currently sitting in the top half of the peloton, the highly bunched up pack of teams stuck from about 45 to 39 points. Tonight’s game against Toronto (currently at the bottom of the pack, 12th place with 40 points) is an important game for both teams. If the Penguins win, not only is that a good thing for the obvious reason of picking up the 2 points, but it also denies a playoff competitor from keeping pace with them. A Toronto loss, coupled with other teams in the pack winning tonight or tomorrow night means they would be in danger of losing touch with the pack.
I wonder how the Penguins will come into this game, physically and mentally. The players said physically after the outdoor game they felt worse and a little sorer than just your average NHL game. Emotionally after such a wild ride (and ending) you have to believe there’s some danger of not having much in the tank and perhaps having a slow start which could quickly compound into a flat performance.
Pittsburgh/Toronto games are almost always wide open, crazy games. I’d set the over/under of total goals tonight at 7.5 and probably still be tempted to take the over. We shall see. I'd like to see an offensive spark plug that hasn't contributed in a while (Sykora, Staal, Malone) create some offensive. A little secondary scoring could probably inspire/spark the big guns to dig even deeper.
Last year the team didn’t have much adversity to deal with and almost coasted to a 105 point season. This year, important players (Marc-Andre Fleury, Max Talbot, Mark Eaton, Gary Roberts) are dropping like flies with long-term injuries and new players like Ty Conklin, Rob Scuderi and Tyler Kennedy are not only stepping into expanded roles, they’re flourishing.
Of the injuries, Talbot is starting to skate a little, but still on his own. His return is probably weeks away to get healthy and in game shape, but we here think his return is definitely on the horizon. After all, when Gary Roberts went down it left the Penguins with 12 healthy forwards, the minimum number. Michel Therrien doesn’t like to change a lineup during a winning streak, so it wouldn’t make much sense to callup a young forward like Ryan Stone or Jonathan Filewich to ride the bench instead of playing in the A. But they haven’t even called up a depth forward like Connor James, and obviously winning streaks don’t last forever. Plus, unfortunately, injuries do happen and another forward could go down or become ill. That the Penguins haven’t called up another forward, seems to indicate, to me, that Talbot may be getting back into the lineup sooner rather than later.
Defensively the Penguins only have 6 healthy blueliners on the roster. However I’m not that surprised about that. All are healthy and playing their respective roles relatively well. The most likely callup, Alain Nasreddine, would have to be exposed to re-entry waivers if they want to call him up. Nasreddine is a pretty decent 6/7 depth defenseman and it wouldn’t surprise me to see another NHL club claim him, especially since he’d only be owed about ¼ of a season’s salary (because the Penguins would be required to pay half of his remaining salary which, at this point in the season, is about half paid). Why expose Naz (a former captain and veteran leader of the Baby Pens) to waivers if you don’t need to? Why callup a guy like Ryan Lannon if he’s just going to sit the bench anyways? Neither scenario makes much sense; as there’s little to gain and much more to lose.
If/when the Penguins need to fill a roster spot that’s when you can try to sneak Nasreddine back up, or look to make a trade for a depth defenseman. Until then, with guys like Sydor and Orpik playing better and Letang playing well in general, it’s OK to me to stand pat.
Back to the game, as I mentioned the Penguins are currently sitting in the top half of the peloton, the highly bunched up pack of teams stuck from about 45 to 39 points. Tonight’s game against Toronto (currently at the bottom of the pack, 12th place with 40 points) is an important game for both teams. If the Penguins win, not only is that a good thing for the obvious reason of picking up the 2 points, but it also denies a playoff competitor from keeping pace with them. A Toronto loss, coupled with other teams in the pack winning tonight or tomorrow night means they would be in danger of losing touch with the pack.
I wonder how the Penguins will come into this game, physically and mentally. The players said physically after the outdoor game they felt worse and a little sorer than just your average NHL game. Emotionally after such a wild ride (and ending) you have to believe there’s some danger of not having much in the tank and perhaps having a slow start which could quickly compound into a flat performance.
Pittsburgh/Toronto games are almost always wide open, crazy games. I’d set the over/under of total goals tonight at 7.5 and probably still be tempted to take the over. We shall see. I'd like to see an offensive spark plug that hasn't contributed in a while (Sykora, Staal, Malone) create some offensive. A little secondary scoring could probably inspire/spark the big guns to dig even deeper.
Tuesday, January 1, 2008
A Winter Classic Indeed
Wow what a game. I can't wait to see the ratings just out of sheer curosity. Game thoughts:
``My initial thought was this game was exactly like the Steelers/Dolphins game. The game conditions were so terrible that you really can't take too much away for either team. You just have to hope you get the bounces and come out on top. In both this hockey game and that Steelers game the total number of points on the final scoreboard was 3, by the way.
``I don't know who wouldn't have faith in Ty Conklin, but he played awesome today. He absolutely held the Pens in it, making numerous great saves left and right.
``Great exchange happened today at my house. A bunch of my friends (who all grew up in Virginia and don't know much about hockey) were watching with me. Obviously they were paying attention today and could tell Sidney Crosby is the face of the league and was the emphasis of the game. Noticing that the game deciding shootout goal was on his stick, one buddy astutely noted:
"Wow this couldn't have worked out any better for the league, the game's #1 bright star with a chance to win it in such an exciting fashion"
I quickly pointed out how the games most skilled players in the game often fail at shootouts and Crosby was but 6 for 20 in such attempts since the beginning of the 2006-07 season.
Aside from being shocked/disgusted that I could recite such a stat another friend remarked: "Yeah, but if he's as good as the hype that we've been watching for the past 3 hours, he's got to bury this".
Instantly I thought of all the Crosby-haters that might understandably get fed up with all the attention he receives. Silently I nodded, he does have to finish it.
Game.
``My initial thought was this game was exactly like the Steelers/Dolphins game. The game conditions were so terrible that you really can't take too much away for either team. You just have to hope you get the bounces and come out on top. In both this hockey game and that Steelers game the total number of points on the final scoreboard was 3, by the way.
``I don't know who wouldn't have faith in Ty Conklin, but he played awesome today. He absolutely held the Pens in it, making numerous great saves left and right.
``Great exchange happened today at my house. A bunch of my friends (who all grew up in Virginia and don't know much about hockey) were watching with me. Obviously they were paying attention today and could tell Sidney Crosby is the face of the league and was the emphasis of the game. Noticing that the game deciding shootout goal was on his stick, one buddy astutely noted:
"Wow this couldn't have worked out any better for the league, the game's #1 bright star with a chance to win it in such an exciting fashion"
I quickly pointed out how the games most skilled players in the game often fail at shootouts and Crosby was but 6 for 20 in such attempts since the beginning of the 2006-07 season.
Aside from being shocked/disgusted that I could recite such a stat another friend remarked: "Yeah, but if he's as good as the hype that we've been watching for the past 3 hours, he's got to bury this".
Instantly I thought of all the Crosby-haters that might understandably get fed up with all the attention he receives. Silently I nodded, he does have to finish it.
Game.
Monday, December 31, 2007
A Long (Successful) December
The only Eastern Conference team to gain more points than the Penguins (18) in December was the conference breakaway team Ottawa Senators (20).
Not bad considering Dany Sabourin and Ty Conklin have been the netminders since December 6th and key players like Max Talbot, Sergei Gonchar, Ryan Malone and Gary Roberts have been injured or missed games during this stretch.
Now it's time for the highest profile regular season game. If you don't know what this is, you're living in a cave.

Bring it. I'm stoked. I'm sure all the players on both teams are going to be laying it all on the line, and even though the conditions are going to be unpredictable, I have a feeling something special is going to take place in this most special of games. Think 87 or 71. I am.
Happy New Years folks. See you tomorrow afternoon with a comprehensive recap.
Google Post of the Week
Today's google searcher that stumbled across this humble blog was looking for:
"Crosby circles the wagon and loses the puck"
We're the top listing for that too!
Happy New Year to everyone! I'll be back a little later with thoughts going into the big game. I'm glad that geography and working on Wednesday makes it impossible for me to even think about going.....Too cold for these bones.
"Crosby circles the wagon and loses the puck"
We're the top listing for that too!
Happy New Year to everyone! I'll be back a little later with thoughts going into the big game. I'm glad that geography and working on Wednesday makes it impossible for me to even think about going.....Too cold for these bones.
Saturday, December 29, 2007
A win but a loss

As [Buffalo forward Tim ]Connolly fell in the left circle in Buffalo's end, the 41-year-old [badass Gary] Roberts went down with him and struck his left leg hard on the ice, breaking his fibula.
A stretcher was brought out but Roberts did not use it.
Did you really expect him to?
Otherwise, a solid 2-0 win. Crosby with 2 assists, Colby and Geno tack on the goals and Ty freakin Conklin has, somehow, inspired conifidence with a shutout.
But at a moment like this, the upcoming weeks/months of not having a veteran warrior like Roberts in the lineup is going to be a challenge. Younger, physical players with experience like Ryan Malone, Colby Armstrong and even Brooks Orpik are going to have to step up and be physical....And in a big way.
But at a moment like this, the upcoming weeks/months of not having a veteran warrior like Roberts in the lineup is going to be a challenge. Younger, physical players with experience like Ryan Malone, Colby Armstrong and even Brooks Orpik are going to have to step up and be physical....And in a big way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
